March 31, 2022

Crapo Statement at Hearing on U.S. Trade Agenda

Washington, D.C.–U.S. Senator Mike Crapo (R-Idaho),
Ranking Member of the U.S. Senate Finance Committee, delivered the following
remarks at a hearing entitled, “The President’s 2022 Trade Policy Agenda.” 

The text of Ranking Member
Crapo’s remarks, as prepared, is below.  

“Thank you, Mr. Chairman.  Welcome Ambassador Tai. 

“On your drive here, Ambassador Tai, you passed an
inscription engraved on the National Archives: ‘past is prologue.’  An
enduring piece of past wisdom is President Reagan’s 1982 address to the nation
on international free trade, which was founded on his personal commitment to
free market principles, both at home and abroad.   

“He explained that as Americans, we must, ‘[I]nsist on sound
domestic policies at home that bring down inflation…’  Provide opportunity
for ‘free world countries [to] go forward and sustain the drive toward more
open markets,’ such as the meeting he organized in Geneva that eventually led
to the creation of the World Trade Organization (WTO).  And—most importantly—negotiate. 
Particularly for free trade agreements, like the United States’ first two free
trade agreements, with Israel and Canada, that were led by Reagan’s
administration. 

“President Reagan’s policies helped to break inflation and
to restore American leadership on trade.  But, it seems President Biden’s
trade policy takes the opposite stance.  At a time when inflation has
soared to 7.9 percent, President Biden says he will not pursue trade agreements
until his domestic agenda is complete. 

“If ever enacted, this reckless spending agenda would not
only make inflation worse, it would undercut U.S. leadership on trade by
promoting a China-styled industrial policy.   

“Proposed electric vehicle provisions, for example, will
discriminate against 48 of the 50 models available for sale in the United
States.  It is no wonder why 25 foreign ambassadors told Congress these
provisions breached our international trade obligations. 

“I am disappointed that the Administration continues to
pursue this agenda, instead of focusing efforts on negotiations for new trade
agreements.  This is a shame because the Biden Administration knows
better.  Its 2022 Trade Agenda opens on the very point—and, I quote—the
‘Biden Administration recognizes that trade can—and should—be a force for
good.’ 

“Absolutely.  My home state of Idaho is proof positive
of that proposition.  In 2019, international trade supported over 200,000
Idaho jobs—or almost 20 percent of the state’s employment.  Trade
liberalization also saves the average Idaho family of four more than $10,000
per year. 

“The problem here is that President Biden’s recognition of
trade’s overall importance is not matched with an agenda that contains the
requisite ambition to succeed.  There is not a single free trade agreement
(FTA) under consideration in this agenda.  Free trade agreements open
opportunities.  We have seen it over and over.  The past really is
prologue. 

“Idaho’s dairy exports to Korea increased by more than 250
percent since our free trade agreement entered into force in 2012.  But,
in lieu of trade agreements, this Administration is proposing dialogues and
frameworks, including the new Indo-Pacific Economic Framework, or IPEF. 
IPEF may be a positive first step to engagement in Asia.  But, it is no
substitute for a comprehensive trade agreement.   

“The Center for Strategic and International Studies will
soon release its upcoming analysis on IPEF, based on conversations with over a
dozen governments in the Indo-Pacific.   

“Two points from its analysis are instructive: 

“First, U.S. engagement is welcome in the
Indo-Pacific.  One diplomat stressed, in particular, that his country
wants the United States to ‘lay out an affirmative economic strategy that complements
its security presence in the region.’ 

“Second, our partners ‘see the IPEF as a proposal with many
U.S. asks, few U.S. offers, and a variety of credible regional alternatives to
the framework that could provide more tangible benefits.’ 

“If the U.S. is to meet and exceed China’s challenge, then
the U.S. must make stronger commitments than China.  Regrettably, if the
Administration’s negotiating ambitions are low, its consultations with Congress
on the few negotiations actually taking place is even lower. 

“At last year’s trade agenda hearing, Ambassador Tai stated
that she would brief this Committee before and after each negotiating session
with respect to a waiver of the WTO TRIPS Agreement.  That hasn’t
happened.   

“USTR recently issued a press release confirming that it had
reached a ‘compromise outcome’ on the TRIPS waiver in discussions with South
Africa, India, and the European Union.  USTR refuses to share the text of
that ‘outcome’ with this Committee.  While members may have different
views on the merits of this waiver, every Member here should agree with me that
the Administration cannot withhold documents concerning U.S. rights under a
congressionally-approved trade agreement.  We need to see the document,
and we need to ask questions, because that is what respect for the Constitution
requires.  

“There are serious questions to be asked.  For example,
last week, South Africa and India joined with Russia and China to establish the
‘BRICS Vaccine R&D Center’ on vaccine cooperation.  Congress should
know whether the text permits South Africa and India to share insights on U.S.
intellectual property with Russia and China.  

“USTR’s transparency with the public is also poor.  The
American innovators who developed the vaccines provided plenty of evidence on
why a waiver is unnecessary, including that 20 billion doses will be produced
this year—more than enough to achieve the World Health Organization’s
vaccination target. 

“The Administration, however, has not shared with the public
any evidence as to why a waiver will get shots into arms any faster.  As
disappointed as I am about negotiations and congressional consultation, I also
have concerns about enforcement.   

“Americans need to compete on a level playing field, and I
appreciate the Administration’s prosecution of two USMCA labor disputes under
the Brown-Wyden mechanism.  Yet, much more can be done.  With respect
to USMCA, agricultural market challenges remain.  Mexico continues to
restrict potatoes and delay approval of biotech crops.  Discriminatory
practices targeting our technology companies are also increasing.  Rather
than launch cases, the Administration appears to be in retreat.   

“For example, the trade agenda highlights that USTR reached
agreements to terminate our Section 301 investigations against various
countries over discriminatory digital services taxes. 

“Let us be very clear about what this means—those countries
are going to continue imposing discriminatory taxes on U.S. firms.  They
may give a credit one day, but only if Congress approves the Biden
Administration’s international tax deal.  The Biden Administration is
blessing foreign governments which discriminate against Americans as long as
Congress refuses to go along with its plan to cede taxing rights and revenue to
foreign competitors.  

“Let me close with where I started—past being
prologue.  History proves that Americans do not fear competition, but rise
to it.  Now is the time to seize on that history and to go further on
trade, not shrink from it. 

“Thank you, Mr. Chairman.”

Print 
Email 
Share 
Share