March 24, 2022

Finance Committee Republicans: Unsustainable Mandatory Spending Will Fuel Inflation Crisis

Washington, D.C.–Republican members of the U.S.
Senate Finance Committee, led by Ranking Member Mike Crapo (R-Idaho), sent a
letter to Senate colleagues highlighting concerns with a proposal to double
down on skyrocketing spending during record-high inflation by extending the
poorly targeted, badly designed Obamacare subsidy hikes, including for
Americans with sizable six-figure salaries.   

Last year, the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) increased the
value of the Obamacare “premium tax credits,” or PTCs, allowing individuals
earning over 400 percent of the federal poverty level to accept the credits for
the first time.  As part of their reckless
tax-and-spending spree, Democrats are seeking to extend the expansion.  

From the letter: 

“Congress should be working to address the harmful
effects of inflation and taking steps to address our ballooning debt crisis,
driven by unsustainable mandatory spending.  The wrong approach is
to double down on skyrocketing spending during record-high inflation
by
extending the poorly targeted and badly designed Obamacare subsidy hikes,
including for Americans with sizable six-figure salaries. . . .” 

“CBO estimates a permanent expansion of the Obamacare
subsidies alone would cost $220 billion over the next decade.
  Instead
of improving the quality of Obamacare plans, this proposal would simply pass
more of the costs onto taxpayers. . . .” 

“The proposal also benefits wealthy Americans more
than those with low incomes.
  Households making above 400 percent of
the federal poverty line (FPL) would benefit far more than those currently
earning near the poverty line, since the latter group is already largely
eligible for subsidy support. . . .”     

“Exacerbating Obamacare’s problematic subsidy design to
the benefit of upper-income Americans only worsens the structural financial
problems facing our health care system. The Administration and Congressional
Democrats should abandon this misguided course of action and instead combat the
scores of real issues facing workers and families.
” 

Full text of the letter is available here and
below.  

_____________________________  

Dear Colleague, 

Americans are all
painfully aware that we now have a 7.9 percent inflation rate — the highest
rate of inflation in 40 years.  Congress should be working to address the
harmful effects of inflation and taking steps to address our ballooning debt
crisis, driven by unsustainable mandatory spending.  The wrong
approach is to double down on skyrocketing spending during record-high
inflation by extending the poorly targeted and badly designed Obamacare subsidy
hikes, including for Americans with sizable six-figure salaries. 

Last year, Congress
enacted a partisan reconciliation bill on a party-line vote, unleashing $1.9
trillion in new spending.  The bill included a provision to temporarily
remove the cap on Obamacare subsidy eligibility, along with measures intended
to make these subsidies even larger, providing a windfall to insurance
companies with minimal benefit for working families. 

While this policy
was initially marketed as emergency relief aimed at assisting Americans harmed
by the pandemic, the Build Back Better Act sought to maintain the expansion of
these Obamacare subsidies. The intent is clearly to make them permanent. 
The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) analysis shows that the entire tax-and
spend bill, absent budget gimmicks, would cost $4.9 trillion and increase deficits
by $3 trillion.   

CBO estimates a
permanent expansion of the Obamacare subsidies alone would cost $220 billion
over the next decade.  Instead of improving the quality of Obamacare
plans, this proposal would simply pass more of the costs onto taxpayers. 
By increasing the size of the subsidies and expanding the scope of those
eligible to take advantage of them, this proposal would move us closer to a
big-government takeover of the American health care system. 

To illustrate the
inefficiency of this expansion, the majority of new spending would actually go
to individuals who already have health insurance coverage.  Analysis from
CBO and the Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT) projected that less than 35
percent of additional dollars for the premium tax credit expansion enacted by
the partisan reconciliation bill would go to previously uninsured people. 
The other $22 billion would be used to pay insurance companies more over two
years to cover people who already had insurance. 

The proposal also
benefits wealthy Americans more than those with low incomes.  Households
making above 400 percent of the federal poverty line (FPL) would benefit far
more than those currently earning near the poverty line, since the latter group
is already largely eligible for subsidy support.  If enacted, Americans
with six-figure salaries could find themselves eligible for taxpayer
subsidies.  In just two years, the federal government is projected to
spend more than $3 billion on subsidies to households making over 750 percent
of the FPL, according to analysis from CBO and JCT, amounting to more than
$164,000 for a household of three for 2021. 

We can and must do
better.  We stand ready to develop and advance bipartisan solutions to
address Obamacare’s numerous fundamental flaws and to make health care more
affordable, accessible, and innovative.  However, exacerbating Obamacare’s
problematic subsidy design to the benefit of upper-income Americans only
worsens the structural financial problems facing our health care system. 
The Administration and Congressional Democrats should abandon this misguided
course of action and instead combat the scores of real issues facing workers
and families. 

Sincerely,

 

Print 
Email 
Share 
Share