October 14, 2021

Crapo, Idahoans Highlight Concerns with IRS Bank Reporting Scheme

BOISE–Idaho’s U.S. Senator Mike Crapo, Ranking
Member of the Senate Finance Committee, joined Idaho leaders, concerned
constituents, and business and financial leaders for a roundtable discussion on
a proposal to create a reporting scheme where financial intermediaries report
to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) on customer deposits and
withdrawals.   

The Biden Administration and congressional Democrats are
considering an $80 billion boost in IRS funding, and implementing a reporting
dragnet under which local banks, credit unions and payment providers will
essentially be turned into agents of the IRS, monitoring and reporting of
inflows and outflows on deposits and withdrawals made in private
accounts.  This proposal raises a number of serious concerns regarding
Americans’ privacy; data security; and a massive amount of paperwork and
confusion for taxpayers and the IRS.  In
light of these proposals to massively expand the IRS with unprecedented amounts
of mandatory funding, and the IRS’s continued abuses of taxpayer rights and
privacy, Senator Crapo has introduced legislation to place important guardrails
around and IRS funding to protect taxpayer rights and privacy, the TaxGap Reform and IRS Enforcement Act. 

From the discussion:  

U.S. Senator Mike Crapo, Idaho, Ranking Member of the
Finance Committee

“I think this is the biggest violation of personal privacy
that has ever even been proposed, let alone enacted, by the United States
government, and it’s something that every American ought to be incredibly
worried about.” 

Idaho State Treasurer Julie A. Ellsworth

“It is an egregious overreach. It is essentially going to be
a daily ongoing audit of every person who are law abiding citizens—at least
give us the opportunity to be accused of something.” 

Idaho State Controller Brandon Woolf

“One of the other big concerns I share as State Controller
is the unintended consequences of what this may bring.  For example, I fear
for our financial institutions of what may happen if people choose to ‘unbank,’
and cybersecurity, which is a daily threat that we deal with constantly.” 

Aaron Briggs, Financial Expert, Boise Wealth Management

“I feel those inflow and outflow boxes, without itemization
on each purchase, leaves open to interpretation for the U.S. government and the
IRS to decide what number they want tax on any account.  The overarching
thing, is they want to bring in more control and to get at peoples data or money.
. . This is supposed to be for high net-worth individuals and billionaires, to
make sure they’re not skirting the issue on paying taxes.  One of the
reasons they included the $600 or above account balance to be monitored, is so
a billionaire or high net-worth individual can’t have multiple accounts to hide
those assets.  I’m sorry, but $600 on someone who is a high net-worth
individual or billionaire; how many accounts are we talking about?  That
doesn’t seem like a good excuse to say that’s why the threshold is $600. 
Really, it is just an overreaching part of the government to monitor
everybody’s accounts.  I don’t think that should be what is done, and I
have clients that feel the same way.” 

Adam Lyman, ABCO Engineering, Nampa

“I spend tens of thousands of dollars preparing my taxes
every year.  It takes months and months to do this stuff just to comply
with what the government requires. . . For people like me, an overregulating
government is putting burdens on us that are restricting the amount of people I
can help.  The best I do every day is know people are paying mortgages
because of my efforts.  And this is just another way to keep me from doing
that for people.  It’s onerous, [and] it’s a violation of privacy. 
The government does not want me to [succeed], obviously.  And this is just
one more brick on the wall to stop me from being successful.” 

Platt Thompson, Idaho entrepreneur

“This invasion of privacy with regard to our personal
finances is particularly egregious; it’s beyond the pale that the government
will be able to observe, mark and data mine all of my transactions.  It is
a horrific proposal for anyone who values personal privacy and more than that,
personal freedom.” 

Jessica Trawick, U.S. Air Force veteran, Rover
independent contractor and Idaho entrepreneur

“I’m starting my own small business and me and people like
me are trying to figure out the tax code and tax law and wondering why we are
being targeted. This hits everyone.  If the highest part of our
population’s wealth is at the top, why is it independent contractors and
low-level small businesses–growing people–being targeted? People within my
small business groups feel we are being unfairly attacked in a system already
designed to make it harder for us to get started.” 

John Evans, Jr., President, D.L. Evans Bank

“The proposal would create a significant burden for small
business, banking and credit unions.  Bankers firmly believe that
Americans should honor their tax obligations, but requiring banks and credit
unions to report every single transaction is just ridiculous to be honest with
you.  Every inflow and outflow coming out of an account is reported. 
And as you mentioned, the IRS is a constant target of cyber criminals, and
recently suffered significant data breaches. . . The regulatory burden for all
of us is just unbelievable.” 

Kent Oram, President and CEO, Idaho Central Credit Union

“The privacy overreach is astounding.  And to
imagine—you know, there is sometimes the way politics goes is we talk about
$600 but then we follow what about $2,000 or what about some other number—well
it doesn’t matter what number, it can be a penny or a million dollars, it
doesn’t matter, it’s the same amount of work on America’s financial
institutions to comply with something like this. . . This is a massive
overreach and we oppose it.”  

Deneen May, President for Western Idaho, Zions Bank

“We are deeply concerned that this proposal would put
customer privacy and data security at risk.  An unprecedented amount of
taxpayer information such as payments on loans, transfer between a taxpayers
various bank accounts, would be captured and recorded.  This information
would be massive and have little relevance to taxable income.  Finally,
the legislation would increase compliance cost to individuals and small
business.  The proposed in-flow and out-flow reporting appears to small
millions of small business owners that operate as sole proprietorships will
needless increase their tax preparations cost.” 

Todd Erickson, President and CEO, CapEd Credit Union

“This is bad policy, it really is.  We’ve got nearly
90,000 members, most of them are consumer accounts, and they look to us to
provide banking services at a low cost to them and also a convenience for them
so they can access their accounts.  But the more regulation that comes to
us, which is already heaped on the many reporting requirements we have already,
consumer protection laws and everything else, is just all that compliance cost
is filtered down to the consumer, to the member.  They end up paying the cost
for this.  And for what purpose?  So the government can spend more
money and they can continue to tax the consumer and small businesses. . . From
the banking and credit union’s perspective, a cybersecurity breach is not a
matter of if, it is a matter of when.  We spend a lot of
money to protect the data of our consumers and our members.  Once the data
is within our house, we can protect it; if we send it out, it is out of our
control; if it goes to the government and that data breach happens, our consumers
will look to us as to why it happened.”  

Charley Jones, Owner, Stinker Stations of Idaho

“It’s an amazing time in the U.S.  I’ve never been
afraid of Big Brother.  But then I see this, and just my head spins. 
You can’t make this stuff up.  I think this is probably proposed by
somebody that’s never signed the front of a paycheck.  I’ve had a business
for over 50 years.  [We] work hard every day to serve our customers, to be
part of America, to be part of this fantastic country.  And then we have
bureaucrats who I guess think that we’re evil.  And we’re not, we’re good
people.  And we work hard.” 

The Administration and congressional Democrats’ proposed
IRS financial institution reporting scheme raises a number of serious concerns:
 

  • Privacy: Existing law protects the privacy of confidentiality
    of personal financial records, and the overwhelming majority of Americans
    honestly report and pay their tax liabilities.  This proposal creates
    unnecessary additional scrutiny with no proven benefit.
     
  • Data Security Concerns: The IRS has an
    extensive history of leaks, hacks and other violations of taxpayer
    confidentiality.  This proposal would put additional troves of
    private taxpayer data at risk of future exposure.
     
  • Low- and Middle-Income Earners Swept In: While proponents of
    the measure argue this bank-monitoring dragnet will focus on the “rich” or
    “billionaires” evading taxes, this scheme will capture everyone with an
    account at a bank, credit union, brokerage, Venmo, Paypal and more. 
    This means individual private accounts, or those with business accounts
    such as plumbers, jewelers, small contractors, and more will be caught up
    in this scheme.
     
  • Drowns Taxpayers and the IRS in a Sea of Information:  The breadth of
    this proposed information reporting dragnet will result in a massive
    amount of paperwork and confusion for taxpayers and the IRS. 
    Taxpayers will be juggling multiple additional forms, the IRS will be
    inundated with paper, and banks will bear increased compliance and
    reporting burdens on their customers.
     

Crapo is taking Idahoans’ concerns back to Washington, D.C.
where he will continue to fight against the IRS proposal and Democrats’
upcoming reckless tax-and-spending plans.  

###

Print 
Email 
Share 
Share