March 19, 2021

Opinion: States Deserve Fiscal Flexibility

WASHINGTON, D.C. – The
following op-ed by U.S. Senate Finance Committee Ranking Member Mike Crapo (R-Idaho) appeared in The Hill. 

The American
Rescue Plan, recently signed into law, contains a number of flaws. Many
provisions appear to have been hastily drafted. Many provisions are vague and
punt hard decisions to various government agencies, presumably under the notion
the issues are hard to figure out but, somehow, government bureaucrats are
expected to do so. 

One example of
this lies in the new Coronavirus State Fiscal Recovery Fund, a slush fund
constructed for the U.S. Department of Treasury to dole out money to states.
Allowable uses of those funds amount to basically anything a state wants to
spend money on, with next to nothing in terms of constraints or restrictions. 

Nonetheless,
there are two
restrictions in the law. 

One is a state may not use recovery funds “for deposit into any pension fund.”
Of course, that does not prevent a state from using funds to beef up other
post-employment benefits for public-sector workers. And, it does not prevent
use of federal funds to make pension payments they would otherwise make using
state funds. So, the restriction is merely window dressing. 

The only other
restriction is that any state wishing to provide tax relief may do so, but only
at a punishable cost. If a state’s net revenue, or some component of net
revenue, falls because of tax relief, then its Coronavirus State Recovery Fund
payment from the federal government will be cut by the amount of the tax
relief. 

What does this
mean? 

Consider, as an
example, the American Rescue Plan’s waiver of federal tax liability on up to
$10,200 of unemployment compensation income. In crafting this legislation, my
Democrat colleagues decided that this form of tax relief is acceptable.
However, suppose a state government decides it would like to waive state
taxation of unemployment compensation income up to some level, in its citizens’
interests. 

The American
Rescue Plan stipulates the state will be financially punished by the federal
government. 

If a state wants
to provide tax relief in the interest of economic recovery, and to help people
return to earning their livelihoods, the American Rescue Plan says the state
will be financially punished by the federal government. 

If a state decides to use funds to replenish depleted Unemployment Insurance
trust funds, so it does not have to raise taxes on employers in the near term
during an economic recovery, it can be financially punished by the American
Rescue Plan. 

My Republican
colleagues and I raised substantive questions about this provision during the
parliamentarian’s consideration of the legislation prior to the vote on the
Senate floor.  

Unfortunately,
Democrats were not interested in providing states the fiscal flexibility to
determine what is best for their citizens. 

What is the
public policy justification of taking away fiscal flexibility and fiscal discretion
to which states are entitled? The drafters of the bill seem to have decided to
make a political statement using denial of fiscal flexibility to states to say
that they do not like tax cuts. Not only is that not good public policy, but it
serves to further divide, rather than advance bipartisanship. 

There are also
significant questions about the legality of the provision, and how the
offending provision could even be implemented. It provides so much latitude for
the administration to decide, at the federal level, what it deems appropriate
or inappropriate state fiscal policy that the Treasury secretary is essentially
unconstrained in implementation. That invites and allows insertion of too much
partisan politics into federal and state relations. 

The vague nature
of the offending provision invites lawsuits. It also injects more uncertainty
into state fiscal policy decisions — as states try to sort out fiscal
priorities and voter wishes, while a potential federal punishment hangs over
them. 

As ranking
member of the Finance Committee, I filed an amendment during debate of the
American Rescue Plan to strike the provision of the American Rescue Plan that
instructs the Treasury Department to financially punish any state or territory
that wishes to provide tax relief to its citizens. I have introduced
identical legislation in the Senate. 

The provision
serves no useful purpose. 

It doesn’t serve
to “rescue” the American people. It interferes in states’ — like Idaho’s —
ability to provide tax relief to its citizens to reduce the burden on working
families. 

It has nothing
to do with the pandemic, and potentially everything to do with partisan
politics.And, as
supporters of the American Rescue Plan must know, it will do nothing more than
impede an economic recovery in states. 

Crapo is ranking member of the Senate Finance Committee. 

###

Print 
Email 
Share 
Share