May 14, 2019

Will corn, chicken and Champagne scuttle a US-EU trade deal?

Will
corn, chicken and Champagne scuttle a US-EU trade deal?

By U.S. Sen. Chuck Grassley of Iowa

 

When trade representatives visit me to discuss biotechnology
products, often the first thing I do is eat a genetically modified kernel of
corn from my farm in New Hartford, Iowa, to show that American biotechnology
products are safe for consumers.

 

In Europe, this wouldn’t be possible. As a World Trade
Organization panel found, the European Union unduly delays approvals for U.S.
agricultural biotechnology. Remarkably, the delays take place even after EU
scientists conclude the products at issue are safe. As trade discussions between the United States and the EU
move forward
, European trade representatives must come to the table
on agriculture.

 

European leaders continually claim that their consumers don’t want
biotechnology products. With no concrete scientific evidence to support their
claims about safety, the EU is simply denying consumers the right to decide
what products they want to buy for their families. But biotechnology isn’t the
only problematic issue.

 

The EU has blocked the importation of U.S. chickens since 1997
because they are treated with antimicrobial baths. However, the EU allows the
importation and sale of vegetables that have undergone the same treatment. This
double standard doesn’t make sense to me, and it wouldn’t make sense to
American poultry farmers if a trade deal was made that didn’t address this
glaring inconsistency.

 

Unfortunately, the EU’s
insistence on excluding agriculture
from trade talks doesn’t come as a
surprise. There have been countless tariff
and non-tariff
barriers imposed on American agricultural products over the
past two decades,

 

For example, the EU has sought to exclude U.S. agricultural
products from European and third-country markets through the use of labeling
rules known as geographical indications that prevent products from carrying
names such as “Champagne” or “Parmesan” that originated in specific regions but
are now in common use. By preventing U.S. agriculture producers from using
commonly accepted names, geographical indications impede the ability of U.S.
producers to market their products abroad.

 

Last week, I met with the EU’s new ambassador to the U.S., Stavros
Lambrinidis. Our discussion centered on trade, specifically agricultural trade.
The EU recently approved its negotiating mandates for a
trade agreement with the U.S. Notably, the bloc wants to exclude agriculture
from the deal. That’s a nonstarter. Members of Congress — Republican and
Democrat, House and Senate — have voiced strong opposition to any agreement
that doesn’t include agriculture.

 

Since any deal negotiated needs to be approved by Congress, the
question needs to be asked: Why should U.S. President Donald Trump’s
administration pursue a deal that seems unlikely to pass in Congress?

 

The U.S. and the EU have enjoyed a special relationship for
decades. The EU bloc of 28 member countries is the U.S.’s largest trading
partner, with more than $1 trillion in trade in 2017. In fact, it’s the largest
bilateral trade and investment relationship in the world.

 

The U.S. and EU economies together account for nearly half of the
world’s gross domestic product and almost one-third of the world’s trade. Given
the importance of this relationship, it’s surprising to me that our friends
across the Atlantic aren’t willing to engage in a conversation about something
as important as agriculture.

 

In a joint statement last July, Trump and European Commission
President Jean-Claude Juncker said they would commission a working group that
would bring the U.S. and EU into a “new phase” of the trading relationship in
which both sides would “win.” They also wrote that they would work toward
making trade “fairer and more reciprocal.” Those goals cannot be achieved if
agriculture is not part of the discussion.

 

The U.S.-EU trade relationship is a significant one. The decisions
made in any bilateral agreement between the U.S. and EU affect economies around
the world. With so much at stake, it’s important to get it right.

 

I’m hopeful that negotiators can work out areas of common
agreement and address political sensitivities. But they must be given the
opportunity. Negotiators shouldn’t be told that a huge sector of the economy is
off limits from the start. It erodes trust between us, discourages compromise
and hurts farmers and consumers.

Print 
Email 
Share 
Share