Prepared Remarks
by Senator Chuck Grassley of Iowa
Chairman of the
Senate Finance Committee
Myths and
Misinformation on 2019 Tax Refunds
Wednesday,
February 13, 2019
Mr.
President,
The
tax filing season began just over two weeks ago. Despite the disruption of the
temporary, partial government shutdown, the IRS reports that all systems are a
go. Tax returns are being processed as normal and refunds are being sent out.
While
there are lingering effects from the shutdown, overall IRS and Treasury have
done a good job of minimizing its effects on tax filers.
This
tax season is receiving additional scrutiny as it is the first time taxpayers
are filing under the tax cuts and reforms enacted by the Tax Cuts and Jobs
Act (TCJA).
My
colleagues on the other side of the aisle and some in the media appear to be
obsessed with finding anything they can manufacture to declare this filing
season a failure for the TCJA. And after only the first two weeks!
Case
in point, last week the IRS released preliminary filing data covering the first
week of filing season.
Immediately,
naysayers began focusing on data that suggests tax refunds in the first week
were down slightly over last year, as well as focusing on anecdotal social
media posts.
Never
mind that the current refund numbers are based on only a few days of data or
that refund statistics can vary widely from one week to the next.
Never
mind that most of the social media posts are unverified. Many have the markings
of a coordinated effort by liberal activists who have regularly used
“#GOPTaxScam” to attack the law on Twitter, despite a vast majority of
taxpayers paying less in taxes.
Yet,
the media falls for it – hook, line and sinker – including such tweets in
articles with no questions asked or verifying the veracity of the claims.
To
be fair, often times buried deep in such articles, well below a sensational
headline, is an attempt to demonstrate some semblance of an unbiased report,
noting that under the TCJA most taxpayers will see a tax cut.
That’s
right. You most assuredly wouldn’t know this from the headlines bemoaning a
reduction in tax refunds, but the vast majority of taxpayers experienced a tax
cut last year – and will this year too.
Every analysis, from the nonpartisan Joint Committee on Taxation, to the
right-leaning Tax Foundation, to the liberal Tax Policy Center, demonstrates
that taxpayers are sending less of their hard-earned money to Washington this
year.
As
an example, an Iowa family of four with the state’s family median income of
around $75,000 stands to see their tax bill cut by more than half, or about
$2,100.
This
is real relief that began appearing in many taxpayers’ paychecks at the start
of 2018.
And
that’s an important point.
The
government could have chosen to deprive this taxpayer of this extra $2,100 last
year until they filed their taxes this year. This may have been the best thing
to do if you are someone who starts with the assumption their money would be
better off in the government’s hands, interest free.
I,
for one, do not. I believe taxpayers know better how to spend their hard-earned
money than Washington.
It
should be up to the individual taxpayer whether it’s in his or her interest to
put that extra $2,100 dollars, or about $175 a month, in a savings account, buy
school supplies for their children, or to help make a car payment.
In
early 2018, Treasury and the IRS implemented updated withholding tables to give
taxpayers just that option.
A
chief priority for the new withholding tables was accuracy. The IRS’ goal was
to help taxpayers get the right amount withheld from their paycheck.
However,
no withholding table will ever be perfect. If they were, there would be no need
for tax refunds. Only what was necessary to satisfy a taxpayer’s tax obligation
would need to be taken from their paychecks.
But,
that is unlikely. Every taxpayer is affected a little differently under the tax
code based on their personal circumstances and some taxpayers incomes may
fluctuate through the year. This makes exact withholding based on general
tables nearly impossible.
As
a result, the amount of a taxpayer’s refund is unlikely to be exactly the same
as it was under the old law. Yes, some taxpayers may a see a smaller refund,
but others may see a larger refund.
But,
the size of one’s refund tells you nothing about whether a specific taxpayer
benefitted under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act or not.
Given
this fact, the best way for taxpayers to see how tax reform affected their
bottom-line is to compare this year’s tax return with last year’s, rather than
on the size of their refund.
Tax
preparers and tax return software often will provide an analysis comparing the
current and previous year’s tax return.
I
encourage taxpayers to compare the total amount of taxes paid this year with
last years. Or, if your income materially changed from last year, compare your
effective tax rate. That’s the taxes paid as a percentage of your adjusted
gross income.
If
your tax preparer does not already provide you with this information, ask them.
If
taxpayers take this approach, the vast majority will see that their tax bill
has gone down. This is what matters, not the size of their refund. The size of
a refund tells you nothing beyond the degree to which a taxpayer has overpaid
their taxes over the course of the year.
I
hope Americans will take the time to check so they can see the real effects
that tax reform has had in their lives.
I
yield the floor.
-30-