April 1, 2022

Inadequate Treasury Engagement on International Tax Negotiations Continues

Washington,
D.C.–
Senate
Finance Committee Republicans, led by Ranking Member Mike Crapo (R-Idaho),
again wrote U.S. Department of the Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen to highlight
the lack of engagement with Congress on its international tax agreement. 
The senators note Treasury has consistently failed to consult Congress in any
meaningful way, nor has it provided the requested data and analysis necessary
for Congress to properly evaluate the effect of its agreement on the U.S.
business community and U.S. revenue.   

From
the letter:  

“[T]he Assistant Secretary asserts there has
been appropriate engagement through briefings provided by Treasury to certain
Congressional staff.  However, these briefings merely informed certain
staff of negotiations after they had occurred, and in most cases, after
developments were publicly announced and the corresponding documents were
publicly released.  After-the-fact briefings with committee and
leadership staff do not constitute meaningful consultation.
”   

“Treasury has also
declined to provide a thorough analysis and the important data that would allow
us to properly evaluate the effect of this agreement on the U.S. business
community and U.S. revenue.
” 

“[T]he Assistant
Secretary’s letter states that Congressional engagement has been ‘valuable in
crafting [Treasury’s] negotiating stances and is ultimately reflected in the
substance of the current agreement.’   We struggle to see how this
is true.
” 

“While Treasury may
have accepted an OECD agreement that will put U.S. companies and jobs at risk, there
is still time to change course given the significant amount of detail and work
that remains to be done.
”   

“Establishing
Congress’s legislative prerogatives is critical to the domestic viability of
any OECD tax agreement.
. . . We urge you and your chief negotiators to
begin fully engaging and consulting with us going forward, starting with
in-person briefings and hearings to discuss these important issues.” 

Finance
Committee Republican members have repeatedly requested engagement, briefings
and information regarding the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and
Development (OECD)/G20 tax agreement, and have received responses from Treasury
that prioritize rhetoric over substance.   

Read
the full letter, signed by all Senate Finance Committee Republican members, here or below.

____________________________________
 

Dear Secretary Yellen, 

While we appreciate the responses to our
December 22, 2021, and February 16, 2022, letters, we would like to again bring
your attention to the insufficient level of engagement and consultation we have
received from this Treasury Department both before and after the Administration
entered into the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
(OECD)/G20 tax agreement.  In response to our December 22, 2021, letter,
the Assistant Secretary for Legislative Affairs stated that “Congressional
input is a priority for Treasury.”  Despite this assertion, we believe
Treasury has continuously failed to engage with us in a meaningful
manner.      

In support of his claim, the Assistant
Secretary asserts there has been appropriate engagement through briefings
provided by Treasury to certain Congressional staff.  However, these
briefings merely informed certain staff of negotiations after they had
occurred, and in most cases, after developments were publicly announced and the
corresponding documents were publicly released.  After-the-fact briefings
with committee and leadership staff do not constitute meaningful
consultation.  Treasury has also declined to provide a thorough analysis
and the important data that would allow us to properly evaluate the effect of
this agreement on the U.S. business community and U.S. revenue.  This
level of engagement does not convey that Treasury views our input as necessary
or critical.  

Further, the Assistant Secretary’s
letter states that Congressional engagement has been “valuable in crafting
[Treasury’s] negotiating stances and is ultimately reflected in the substance
of the current agreement.”  We struggle to see how this is true.  In
a reversal from the prior Administration, the Biden Treasury Department failed
to negotiate for current U.S. law to be deemed compliant under Pillar Two, in
direct opposition to comments received from us and our staff. 
Additionally, we, along with many of our Democratic colleagues, have voiced
support for the foreign-derived intangible income (FDII) provision, yet
Treasury has conveyed to OECD countries that FDII will be “abolished.” 
Similarly, had the Administration actually consulted Congress (rather than
merely point to a 2020 “blueprint” after the fact) on whether the agreement’s
provision of more favorable treatment to refundable tax credits than to
nonrefundable tax credits was an acceptable negotiating outcome, we clearly
would have said it was not and advised you to protect U.S. tax incentives to
ensure our businesses and workers do not face a competitive disadvantage. 
 

Despite the Assistant Secretary’s
request for input on the marketing and distribution safe harbor in his recent
letter, the Assistant Secretary does not provide any data on the “tradeoffs,”
specific options on the table, or any meaningful information to allow us to
provide constructive feedback.  Such actions do not reflect a Treasury
Department that believes Congress should play a meaningful role in these
negotiations, or that its views should be taken into account.  

While Treasury may have accepted an OECD
agreement that will put U.S. companies and jobs at risk, there is still time to
change course given the significant amount of detail and work that remains to
be done.  As the recently proposed EU directive acknowledges, the clearly
unrealistic timeline is already slipping, and there is ample time for Treasury
to begin taking into account what Congress, which has sole tax-writing
authority under the U.S. Constitution, is willing and able to enact into
law.    

Establishing Congress’s legislative
prerogatives is critical to the domestic viability of any OECD tax
agreement.  As we have stated many times, implementation of this agreement
would require Congressional action, including Senate approval of a multilateral
tax treaty.  We urge you and your chief negotiators to begin fully
engaging and consulting with us going forward, starting with in-person
briefings and hearings to discuss these important issues. 

Sincerely,

 

Print 
Email 
Share 
Share